Haunted Hotels in Staten Island, New York You Can Stay In

The Historic Old Bermuda Inn

301 Veterans Road W, Staten Island, NY 10309

Originally built in the 1830s, the inn is believed to be haunted by Martha Mersereau, who died of grief after her husband perished in the Civil War. Her spirit is reportedly seen roaming the dining room and stairs. Staff and guests report feeling watched, hearing unexplained noises, and witnessing unusual events like a portrait of Martha catching fire, malfunctioning lights, and disembodied whispers.