Haunted Hotels in Bayfield, Wisconsin You Can Stay In

Old Rittenhouse Inn

301 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814, United States

The Old Rittenhouse Inn is known for local ghost stories discussed on the 'Bayfield Ghost Walk.' Reports include sightings of a tall figure in white on the front porch. A more specific tale involves 'Winnie,' the daughter of the original owner, Judge Joseph Atkinson. Winnie, who never had children, is said to playfully interact with children staying in the house, sometimes appearing as a lady in a green plaid dress at the foot of their beds or tickling their toes.